what to do with politicians!

In a number of posts, I have written to decry the apparent greed of our politicians and specifically those in the 11th parliament whose main business since they were sworn in has been to demand a higher pay, threaten to disband the statutory body charged with determining salaries for state officers and threats to blackmail the executive by paralyzing the finance bill unless their demands are met. Oh and they have ordered the press out of the media centre and will only cover parliament on invite basis!

To digress, one can easily be disillusioned by politicians and see it is a hopeless case. In fact, one would suggest that the office of the politician be done away with completely and replaced by some ad hoc committees that would sit for a specified period then disband. It has been argued that the legislature checks the excesses of the executive. Someone tell me how this is possible when the majority in the legislature are members of the governing party, they have a majority in the parliamentary committees and all the members from whatever party are united in rapin’ the taxpayer! The press can’t check the government since the leaders have the biggest shares in the major media houses. The civil society tries its work but I think it is not systematic and consistent.

In the past we have had commissions [Cocker commission and Akiwumi] to review the salaries paid to our members of parliament and all the commissions have always recommended that the MPs be paid handsomely to cushion them from corruption, to allow them to live in dignity[read live in gated communities away from their poor constituents], to own a good car[the bigger the better] and so on. The Akiwumi report recommended that in order for MPs to pay tax on their allowances, something they ought to have been doing, their salaries had to be increased to cushion them from loss in income. The members of the commission argue here that the ILO statutes do not allow reducing the pay of an employ or something of that kind which I agree with but that was not relevant here. These men and women had not been remitting money to the revenue authority illegally and as such this couldn’t be construed as reducing their salaries per se but correcting a wrong which had been allowed to go on for long.  It was therefore a sigh of relief when the SRC in their wisdom recommended that the salary paid to the members of the house be reduced to reflect the state of our economy and to match their job group [what job group is MP?]. It is this that they have been contesting since they were sworn in.

Kenya is ranked among the poorest countries in the world where a great majority of the population live below the WB and IMF poverty line of a dollar a day, there is endemic unemployment and those who are employed are more often than not underpaid or underemployed. It is therefore disturbing that those who claim to be their representatives in demanding higher salaries for themselves do not take into account the financial reality of the country. We pay our MPs more or close to the same amount of money MPs in our donor countries are paid, talking about a beggar insulting his benefactor!

Even though I find politicians to be lost causes, there is one president, President Jose Mujica of Uruguay, who stands high above the rest of them. This is a man who when he became president,

chose not to accept the chauffeur-driven police escort to the elaborate presidential palaces of La Residencia de Suarez. Instead, on that victorious evening, Mujica drove home to his wife Lucia at their modest farmhouse on the outskirts of Montevideo in one of his few owned assets, a 1987 Volkswagen Beetle. It was a simple and modest act that was to be the cornerstone of Mujica’s political direction from then on.

Whereas am not asking our MPs or anyone else for that matter to donate their earnings to charity, I want to point out that greed is not the only way to serve the rest. I hope that it can be said of MPs, as Col R. Ingersoll said of Abe Lincoln, here is a man when he had great power he used to for the good of his fellow-man. Am hoping that they will be reasonable and realistic, but over and above this I hope they will come to the realization that we do well without them and as such they could disband the national assembly or reduce its size considerably and look for work elsewhere.

 Related articles

ICPSK submission[pdf]

Kenyan MPs double their salaries again in a new bid to evade taxation

what does your mp actually get

MPs want Uhuru suspended for opposing MPs salary hike

Kenya MPs Pay – Adoption of Akiwumi Tribunal Report on MPs Pay – Motion and Debate – Hansard Wednesday 30th June, 2010

simple living: president of Uruguay leads by example

About makagutu

As Onyango Makagutu I am Kenyan, as far as I am a man, I am a citizen of the world

15 thoughts on “what to do with politicians!

  1. Ishaiya says:

    I only studied Kenyan socio-economic politics for a short time as part of my degree program a few years back, so I know very little of the situation as it stands in your country, however I do find it very interesting. Very nicely written article. I shall have to follow up on some of your links. I hope the evening is treating you well my friend.


    • makagutu says:

      I am well my friend and I hope you too are.

      Our political situation is a comedy of sorts, socio-economic is intriguing since the World Bank reports shows the economy is growing steadily, the disposable cash seems to be in the hands of a few, prices of basic commodities went above the ceiling eons ago, decent housing is beyond the rich of the majority, health facilities are run down and our schools are understaffed. In short we have a plethora of problems made worse by a political class that is largely unaccountable to the employer.


  2. Mordanicus says:

    People enter politics, mostly, because they are unfit for other careers. There was once a top physicist who declined an offer to become president of some state, because he valued his contribution to theoretical physics much more important. The same is true for successful business people. People who are able to do real things, choose for non-political careers.


    • makagutu says:

      Some of the politicians are the best legal minds, social scientists and engineers the country has produced but as soon as they get to parliament, it appears to me one of the requirements as soon as they get to the house is to forget whatever they had learnt till that time and become pricks and idiots. It is sad!

      As long as we have the same crop of politicians, there is likely to be no change on how they will rule. It will be mostly a downward spiral until such a time that people can’t take it anymore, then we will be ripe for a revolution.


      • Mordanicus says:

        One of my teachers, a molecular biologist, told us once that he was disappointed when one of his colleagues, one of the best cellular biologists of the Netherlands, made a career switch and became the Minister for Education. (That guy, the MoE, is now Minister of Interior affairs.)


  3. aguywithoutboxers says:

    My Nairobi brother, the same situation is probably applicable to politicians everywhere, not just Kenya. Politics is not a profession noted for scruples, which is why we have the adage: “Power corrupts.” The solution? Maybe shoot them all after one term in office? I’m not an advocate of violence but, at times, that option does appear viable! Much love and naked hugs!


    • makagutu says:

      Now that is a solution I would support for greater good. I think if it was done once or twice, the next group of politicians will not try the same tricks 😛 except we can never be sure. The best is to abolish political offices and then we have no one to kill and at least we will be complaining about something else.
      Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely and it is no wonder politicians like god.


  4. Mordanicus says:

    Maybe we should abolish elections, and select legislators by lottery from the general populations and that in shifts, as in the US senate.

    Another useful idea might be, that every change in the salary of politicians has to be approved by popular vote, by a 5/6 majority.


  5. Arkenaten says:

    Being just ”up the road” from me you will, I’m sure, be glaringly aware of the excesses of the glorious (barf) ANC.- including government ministers car allowance.


    • makagutu says:

      From down south, what gets to our media houses is the mining strikes or when the good president increases his brood. I didn’t think your politicians were equally greedy


  6. Persto says:

    Hi Makagutu,

    I will be responding to your comment on Eric’s blog at the LoR. James posted the link for the LoR right above your comment on Eric’s blog. Once you’re on LoR just click on religion and irreligion.



We sure would love to hear your comments, compliments and thoughts.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s