Blessed are the doubters: for they shall not be easily fooled.”
― Aniekee Tochukwu
Thanks to Gary, he shared this link on a thread where some of you might not see it. It is a good read worth your while.
Blessed are the doubters: for they shall not be easily fooled.”
― Aniekee Tochukwu
Thanks to Gary, he shared this link on a thread where some of you might not see it. It is a good read worth your while.
An Inclusive Site Dedicated to Life-Long Learning
Any thoughts worth writing about
On the lookout for more joy
Observations and reflectionsf
You - philosophical, thoughtful, witty. Me - still thinks fart jokes are funny. We should DEFINITELY get together!
Questioning the conventional wisdom
Everything random... At 3am 😊
These are unedited versions of my thoughts straight from the mind, a relieve from the ‘pressure cooker’, snippets and flotsam of a mundane existence, collected over time, at the early morning hours at sunrise. I have no intensions to start a self-help group or a forum for complains!
Blossoming: A Story of Beauty, Pain, Struggle & Growth
The African Environmental Blog site
The world inside my head is beautiful 🌷🌷
Videos of feral cats on the streets, and my own four feral felines at home, feline humor, advice, and gifts for your cat.
My journey to finding love through the sea Fuckboys
A blog by the Global Governance Centre, Graduate Institute, Geneva
Nicole
Cogito Ergo Sum
Sustainable Living & Wildlife Conservation
Where The Eagles Fly . . . . Art Science Poetry Music & Ideas
One minute info blogs escaping the faith trap
Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t…
Mark and Abbie Jury
Life is intuition woven on fickleness.
Life is a journey. Let us meet at the intersection and share a story.
Random musings about everything.
With(out) Predicates
I call architecture frozen music. – Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
Just read it. Excellent. I had read of the significance of the lamb sometime ago but this was well argued, and so simple to understand, and the more one comes across such arguments the more the feeling that it is a complete fiction from beginning to end.
LikeLike
It is a simple read.
Unklee and his scholars’ consensus might still find room to believe.
LikeLike
The standard argument is the Traffic Accident analogy Singer uses.
It is similar to the one Habermas, among others, uses.
It’s funny, after reading the article I sat and tested my own memory.
Less that twenty years ago I took my kids to see the Rolling Stones when they played Jo’berg and I;ll be damned if I can remember much detail other than one or two moments and the nice feeling it brings back.
Is it possible such large volumes of work could have been composed by ”eyewitnesses” or even second or third hand accounts?
No chance.
The writer of Mark wrote his and the others simply copied and embellished.
LikeLike
I will grant them faulty reporting and take away divine inspiration. It’s their choice which they want to go with but they can’t have both.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Several billion believers might argue that point!
LikeLike
They can and they should but they will not make an inch without admitting that divine inspiration is fallible and can be misleading.
I would love to hear an apologist debate it
LikeLike
God works in mysterious ways, remember?
LikeLike
The jail break card. I know it
LikeLike
Nice piece. Thanks for the link. It is a well written argument. Jeebus and his zombiefaction are fictions, I do believe.
LikeLike
Fictions that don’t even agree.
How bad were they at writing fiction back then?
LikeLike
They needed a good editor. Guess those hadn’t been invented yet.
LikeLike
What was the role of god in all this? He sat by and watched as his minions did dirty work?
LikeLike
He was involved in a poker game with Osiris, Odin, and Zeus. He’s as shocked as anyone else about the stupid shit idjits wrote about him. If you mix this fact in with the fact he doesn’t actually exist, you get a book of hooey written by bronze age magic men that makes no sense and contradicts itself all over the place.
LikeLike
I have a feeling he was watching a game of American football and supporting the winning team.
LikeLike
God always favors the winning team. That’s the only way they could win. 🙂
LikeLike
Lazy beings, these gods are
LikeLike
They are. You’d think the least they could do is actually exist. Jeez! What lazy bastards.
LikeLike
How hard is it to do just that? How can an omnipotent being be so lazy that it can’t even say hi.
LikeLike
Indeed.
LikeLike
Note to future religion inventors: Do not create such a convoluted, discrepency ridden account of your religions beginnings. Get together beforehand and set the facts…err claims in stone. Everbody get on the same page first, then tell your story… err lies. That way no one can backtrail your story, I’m sorry- lies, and see the scam. Oh also try sprinkling in some common well known facts that might lend credence to your story, damn it- lies. You know stuff like drink milk to make you grow big and strong, or wash your hands after you wipe your ass, or rats carry the plague, not demons. You need some sort of believeability right from the start, to keep assholes like us from showing how fucking stupid you religion really is.
Geez people are stupid.
LikeLike
Oh my shelldigger friend, your advice has come quite late for Mormons, Muslims, Christians, Jews and many more but I hope those who intend to invent a religion in the future will follow your advice
LikeLike
Maybe they figured if they were pious enough, and angry enough when questioned about their inconsistencies, that everyone would simply lend them the airs of legitimacy.
While that does seem to work, it still seems silly to start off by drilling so many damn holes in their boats. Though it is kind of funny watching them try to plug them.
LikeLike
Maybe they never saw any holes.
Do you think Ellen G. White saw any holes in her composition?
LikeLike
Good point. I’ll admit I had to go read up on Ellen White. (damn you Mak!) My initial response would be, I think that rock thumped her on the head pretty good. 🙂 May have been some lasting damage there…
LikeLike
I apologise my friend 🙂
I will start charging you a small fee.
It must have been a brick launched the night using some mechanical device
LikeLike
Oh, so now I’m getting charged for being forced to go Google stuff and read up on it. I suppose the internet has won. lol
I really didn’t see anything profound in her supposed visions. I guess you have to be wearing the babble glasses to get it. I seem to have misplaced mine.
LikeLike
And she has followers! You can from that tell how uncritical people generally are.
The Internet is winning
LikeLike
wow! Just rode my bicycle right by her estate last week! THAT is why there are so many Adventists in St. Helena, CA
LikeLike
There are many Adventists here too. Strange things happen I tell you.
To confound matters, I have even seen first scientist church in Nairobi
LikeLike
L. Ron Hubbard tried this with Scientology. Don’t know if it worked, as that “religion” is too scary for me to even bother looking into. Its followers redefine the words “whack-jobs.”
LikeLike
I have not ventured to find out about Scientology. Life is short and Christianity has enough crazy to occupy several lifetimes
LikeLike
That’s what my mother said when we watched a documentary about it. Maybe it’s because I wasn’t brought up in a religions, but to me they’re all the same. I don’t worry about the details of Christianity. You talk about the details and I’m still stuck on the god part.
Though it is funny, when you stop and think about it. All the more “sophisticated” believers like to say that all of the details are symbolic or metaphorical and their god is this big abstract thing. Yet every religion has crazy stories. None ever really seem to stop with, “Well, there’s this big abstract loving thingamabob that unites all of us, but I can’t tell you much more because we don’t understand it.” No, they always want something more than that. First, it’s the crazy stories. Then, for some reason, it always comes down to what you can eat and who you can fuck. Strange, that.
LikeLike
It is strange, my dear friend, what believers really want. It is impossible to reconcile an abstract being and its concerns about who fucks who and eats what. That most people die without finding there was something wrong with this belief is, in my view, an injustice to them
LikeLike
And none of them ever simply toss out the bible. Oh, they’ll claim it isn’t literal, and it’s just stories, but they all still pretty much cling to and read from the book. When your holy book, literally believed or not, is filled with homicide, genocide, prejudice, and endorsed slavery by the “god” in it, it’s time to toss out the fucking book. “Oh, but there are nice parts, too,” they’ll say. Then tear those out. Stick em in a new book, and toss out the disgusting shit. Little respect for these folks, have I. I’ve more for fundies who don’t try to wiggle out of the fact their book and their god are hate-filled and ugly as shit. They embrace it and live their lives accordingly-like a-holes, but at least they’re honest a-holes. $Amen$
LikeLike
There are NT Christians but then they still tell you sin came to the world through Adam. Why do they want to have it both ways?
LikeLike
That is quite the package of assorted nuts. 🙂
LikeLike
That epigram needs to be put on a button.
LikeLike
Or printed on t shirts
LikeLike
Nice read. If Christianity has taught me anything, it’s to be critical.
LikeLike
Glad you liked it.
LikeLike
Mak, that is an excellent article. It is interesting to read the Jewish perspective as distinct from the Christian presentation of the Jewish perspective.
A few years back when I was studying the New Testament at Seminary I was especially struck by the Book of Acts. Because it occurred to me that one of the major themes in that book was to seek to explain why the majority of Jews rejected Jesus as the Messiah. This article presents a good counterbalance.
LikeLike
Hi Peter,
In your studies of Acts, what was the judgement on its authenticity?
LikeLike
At the time I studied, I assumed Acts was absolutely authentic. My seminary did not explore the critical theories on Acts. So after studying Acts I still considered it a historical work. However after studying Acts (and other parts of the Bible) I built up a list of queries (issues) that kept increasing until in recent months the dam wall burst.
When I studied Acts I was confused by things like James quoting the LXX version of Amos in Chapter 15 at the perhaps most crucial decision made by the early church. It would not have been so critical if not for the fact that the Hebrew version of that part of Amos had quite a different meaning. This puzzled me and was one of those little drips that over time can wear down a mountain.
When I studying in seminary I tended to avoid the critical scholars as I knew they were works of the Devil! This is why I can appreciate how Christians don’t even want to hear the arguments, As I was once like that myself.
LikeLike
Thanks very much, Peter.
Your comment on the quotations from Amos are much in line with a book am currently reading on the Acts. And the conclusion of the author is that the author is unknown but most of it is the composition of one person who was more likely a sympathizer with the Apostle of the Gentiles than with those of the circumcision.
LikeLike
Here’s the beautiful irony: nobody is better than pointing out the silliness of a particular religion than sincere devotees of another religion. Here is something I saw years ago on the web by an anonymous commenter: Mythology is someone else’s religion, sufficiently different from your own for its silliness to be obvious.
LikeLike
In deed. My own deconversion was sped up by reading literature by Muslims on Christianity and luckily for me, I at the same time applied their reasoning to Islam.
LikeLike
I read an amazing screed by a hard core fundie Christian pointing out how scary and febrile Islam’s founding mythos is. THIS person, through the lens of hard core Fundie Christianity, made a rather “convincing” (in a mythological way) case that Muhammad had been deceived by demons.
Wish I could find it, as it is amazing (and a bit funny for an outsider)
LikeLike
Should you find it, please share. That must be a funny read
LikeLike