I will, as with Socrates in Euthyphro, ask what is good.
The author of can you be good without god wants us to believe that without following his holy book we are incapable of being good. And good, he tells us is what the Koran says is good. He tells us reason or ends are not required, blind obedience is what counts.
He writes,
What is needed in a system of morality is not the end goal, but actually clear directives on which actions are right and which are wrong, covering all conceivable contexts. This is what the Qur’an in particular, claims to achieve.
Had this been the case with the Koran or any holy religious book, interpretation or exegesis would be unnecessary. If the bible directs you to kill your neighbour for working on Sabbath, there is no debate. If the Koran says kill the infidel, it is absolute.
I, for the life of me, do not know how one can arrive at a conclusion that
Humanism is therefore no more than a formalised system of convincing yourself that what you are doing is for the betterment and wellbeing of others.
Maybe this fellow understands humanism to mean something different from what I know it to mean or represent. Put simply we are capable of solving our problems and no god above will do anything to improve our lot.
But he lies when he writes
People try to claim that it is religion which is utilised as a pious front for the doing of evil, and that more people do evil in the name of God than for any other reason. This may be the case but there is a difference here – people do evil in the name of God, in spite of the clear teachings of various religions on which actions are right and which are wrong. Humanism on the other hand has no teachings which could act as a buffer against the evil done in its name.
For example, the directive in the bible to not suffer a witch to live was used as a justification for the witch burnings and similar commands appear in the Koran as justification for jihad, which is English for killing for god or is it Allah! And humanism has many teachings that one could look to if one were interested. And these go thousands of years before some pedo dreamed the Koran into existence.
When our author writes
It is also worth asking the question that “what makes a good, moral person?”
it is evident, at least in my view, that they are asking the wrong question. The question that ought first to be settled is what is good, what is moral. The question Socrates wants dispensed with in the Euthyphro. And I don’t think this author has addressed this small matter of definition.
What is instinct? Is there a difference between when a person acts instinctively and when they just act? I am even confused here.
It may be true, I don’t know, that
Humanism gives no directives and no instruction on what action is right in which context and which action is wrong in which context, it totally falls short of defining morality.
but I will say without fear of contradiction that neither does the Koran nor any religion for that matter deal with all available scenarios or even any scenario. All we have from the hot heads who make religious proclamations is don’t do this or that and why because god, speaking through me commands it. If any precept is empty in directing human conduct, religion must be the most empty.
When our author writes
Humanists can also look to the human conscience, but in doing so, they are admitting that morality is a universal and absolute concept.
I am convinced he failed his philosophy classes. The conclusion that morality is universal and absolute is not arrived at by admitting human conscience as a guide. And while still on it, if human conscience is the guide, the it makes moot any need for gods and proves the case of the humanist.
I am yet to read a religious book that has as a context a starving mother forced to steal to fend for her starving children. If there is, I am open to correction.
There is a lot of material on the internet dealing with this question. Anyone with an internet connection has access to so many, it is depressing that most people with such access write such silly things about atheism.
It’s Friday Mak. Therefore, beer is good🍻
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, beer at the right temperature
How are you today?
Me well, have had a good day, a relaxed afternoon and now about to go home.
LikeLike
Hi friend. Not bad thanks. Working on a book but distracted myself with blogs! Not good. OK good, but not productive. Have a great weekend Mak 🙂
LikeLike
Blogs can be a bad distraction. All afternoon I had planned to read some book. I didn’t even open a page. Great weekend to you as well
LikeLike
A work book. I hope?
LikeLike
Yes, a novel. You know the way they describe buildings?
LikeLike
Romantically, not literally, usually.
LikeLike
My Friday afternoons are usually easy unless there is a deadline.
Most times, architecture I only need to look at pictures.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good to see some Muslim apologists producing content.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You would replace Koran with bible and it would have been written by a christian. Do these people read? What’s the Internet for really?
LikeLike
Cute kitten videos, haven’t you heard?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think this group knows about those
LikeLike
I predict one day cute kitten videos will produce peace on earth. This is what our feline overlords want. Man may have domesticated the dog, but it is the cat that domesticated man. All of human history is directed to one thing – creation of the internet so we can properly worship the cat with cute kitten videos. One day, the cutest kitten video ever will cause the whole world to say “Awww.” The Christians have it all wrong. It’s not “awe,” it’s “Awww….” Then we will all melt into a great big puddle and all war, suffering and conflict will cease.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Meow!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cats will be the salvation of humanity and that is why we have internet
LikeLiked by 2 people
It was Teddy Roosevelt who used to say, “Humanists are all cannibals and immoral because they don’t follow the Koran/Bible/Bulfinch’s Mythology. So, follow a god damn holy book or eat babies. Either way, have a nice day.”
LikeLike
If the goddamn book says kill your neighbour, do it, a god commands it
LikeLike
$Amen$
LikeLike
LikeLiked by 2 people
Is that in the Koran? If no, doesn’t work
LikeLike
Many years ago I took Ethics, a philosophy class (I’d already taken Logic). The professor was one of the local priests. That alone I thought was interesting since most of our priest professors were from one of the big orders like the Jesuits or Dominicans (loved their white robes after years of black ones everywhere). One of the things that was also very interesting was his definitions of ethics and morality. Ethics, he explained was a system of behavior and a system for determining whether a certain behavior was a good thing to do or not. It was totally based on human reason and the study of the world around us. Morality on the other hand was a system of behavior also, but it was something handed down by Divine revelation. (i.e. found in the local holy book)
Since most of the noise I hear in the world about morality has to do with sexual behaviors, I do believe that he was correct. The “Divine revelations” concerning how humans should behave towards themselves and each other concerning sex is horrible. Let’s dump morality and stick to Ethics which we can discuss like civilized intelligent humans, OK?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Had your priest, Mariah (missed you from TA), read the stories of Joshua’s genocide of the Canaanites –?
LikeLike
Hi.
Let’s learn to be nice with each other. That will take us along way
LikeLike
I have to wonder if I started killing my neighbors for working on the sabbath, using the bible as my reference, would that be an issue in the god soaked south? If so, why?
If I killed one of my kids for denying the dog, using the bible as my reference, would that be an issue?
If the next town over (pick a direction) refused to follow my beliefs, and I decided to wipe them out entirely, using the bible as my reference, would that be allright?
These morons need to consider the entirety of their magic books before they go spouting off on moral matters.
I think this was based on the Koran, but is there a difference really?
LikeLiked by 1 person
You will go to heaven if you followed da book. It says right there in the book.
LikeLike
That book also says it is true. Therefore it is true!
Religious logic in a nutshell…
LikeLike
You catch on very fast!
LikeLike
Well, they didn’t give me a gold star in kindergarten for nuttin!
LikeLike
You should claim more awards
LikeLike
I hereby claim IBTD1’s Nobel prize!
LikeLike
Damn you!
LikeLike
Lol 🙂 It sure looks pretty on the mantle.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Me either – I had to pay them.
LikeLike
So…what is the going rate for gold stars? I could use a few more to pad my resume 🙂
LikeLike
It’s a negotiation process.
LikeLike