by Jerry Mander
is one of those books I would hardly recommend for anyone. I must admit I didn’t read it to the end but read two thirds of it which means I have earned some right to say something about it.
The argument that TV makes it possible to have the masses have almost the same thoughts or be exposed to the same story or image can be said of newspapers or any media that has a wide circulation. An argument can also be made that Jerry makes his people robots, that they can’t chose when to hit the off switch on their TVs or whatevers.
Jerry’s argument against TV is not limited to TV programming but includes the TV as a medium. And it does seem to me that he would not make allowance for using TV to watch youtube or any docuseries. TV is bad and that is the end of story. If he was writing the book today, would he make the same argument against smartphones and many social media apps that have the potential to be addictive. They may not be harmful.
Since I had not made an appearance on the world stage in 1978, I don’t know how ads were done then but as we speak, there is very important function that ads play in our lives. Without ads, I wouldn’t know whether HP has produced a better comp with much better graphics card and that I should replace my workhorse or maybe where I can bury myself in unhealthy meat burger with honey, cheese, onions and I don’t know what else they put in it. While on ads, an argument can be made that some ads cause harm. Should they be allowed to play on TV? I would say no. But that’s me.
TV is useful for education. And I think it can serve democratic ends though this can be difficult when the TVs and newspapers are owned by oligarchs who may not be interested in democracy or as we have seen with the American media engineering consent for war among the citizens.
Jerry talks of bias embedded in the TV medium but i think bias cannot be avoided in any medium. It can be reduced through objective reporting or allowing for the airing of dissent. And there is bias even in newspapers, books and internet articles.
The only thing going for the book is that it is easy to read though I don’t think it needed to have so many pages. His message could have still been argued in fewer pages.
I agree with the idea.
I pretty much gave up watching TV, somewhere around 30 years ago.
Yes, I still watch some, because my wife turns it on. But I prefer to listen to radio news and to read. TV distorts by putting too much emphasis on what gives good pictures.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I watch YouTube on TV. Or the occasional movie.
Newspapers are not my thing generally. I prefer books anytime
LikeLike
I think we are lucky in the UK with our TV though we didn’t let our children watch ITV which was the main channel with adverts. The BBC does seem to show some bias but I sometimes wonder that, since both the left and the right complain of bias, maybe they have it about right. There are some excellent documentaries, dramas and programmes for children so I can’t agree with your writer that TV is inherently bad.
LikeLike
I am of the same thinking. TV is not inherently bad.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I watch TV all the time but nothing happens on it. Perhaps I should I turn it on next time I watch it. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe you have not even connected the power cords. Next time check those first then try to turn it on
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ive been a fan ot TV since my dad brought home our first set, a Dumont, in 1949. yes, that’s a LONG time. And I was a faithful follower of it until we got our first computers, and when I went online for the first time in 1996 and someone answered me back, I was lost, lost.
I still watched it, sporadically, but then someone decided that TV would not only be pay TV it would be cable, and the set itself was so complicated to turn on, at that stage I said to hell with it.
end of story. While it lasted, it was great fun, but I think we have moved away from it, into another place. For good or not, I don’t know. But there is a LOT of it…
LikeLike
When I was growing up, there was no TV in our house and I don’t think anywhere nearby. There was no electricity you see & solar panels were not cheap. My first interaction with computers I think was when I first got to college. So in a way I have grown without TV and for some reason I have not become such a great fun. I enjoy books more
LikeLike
I watch very little television. Mostly with friends, and since they are “social isolating,” the Sunday dinners-and-Westworld sessions have been on pause. 😦 He even gave me his Netflix password, but by myself, I just can’t be bothered to sit through an hour or more.
Now….the internet was a terrible, terrible thing. 🙂 Without the Internet, how could I be arguing politics with New Zealand Quaker or a Kenyan Architect or the divine midget and future Maximum Leader of the American Empire (inspired by the divine)?
YouTube is a time sink. I am far too old for it, but….
LikeLike
YouTube can eat all the time you have in a day if one is not careful.
LikeLike
I enjoy TV a lot. And also I love books.
LikeLike
Tv can take away book time. How do you create the balance
LikeLiked by 1 person
You could always put TV on a station that you don’t like … which might motivate you to read … 😉
LikeLike
Good idea! Put on Fox News from the US! That’ll work for ya!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe I do that with CNN international or as trumpsky says, fake news.
LikeLike
Gawd. A coupple of times I was plodding away on the gym treadmill (Remember gyms. I wonder if we will ever have them again?) and the television in front of me was tuned to THAT CHANNEL. It truly is something like the old Pravda or what I imagine North Korean television is like. I had to get off the machine and move.
LikeLike
I tried going to the gym once and gave up.
LikeLike
Now this is an idea I hadn’t thought of. I prefer the station off mostly
LikeLike
Free-to-Air is fantastic in Australia. It’s horrible in every other country I’ve visited/lived in. What I want is to chose my cable package, and pay accordingly. Sadly it seems the big providers aren’t interested providing that model.
LikeLike
John: Are you back in Australia, or still in Make Brazil Great country?
LikeLike
Land of Insane, Brasil.
LikeLike
Hahaha.
Bolsonaro and family are on charge making Brazil Great Again
LikeLike
What. A. Mess.
LikeLike
The mind boggles. I mean Lulu, like all politicians, was corrupt. But geezzzzzz.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bolsonaro holds the trophy
LikeLike
Big providers appear to have no time for the few people who want to choose what they will watch and pay for that only
LikeLike
[…] via Four Arguments for the elimination of Television — Random thoughts […]
LikeLike
I used to have a t-shirt that said “Television ate your children”. It got a lot of comments.
LikeLike
I guess the comments must have been interesting
LikeLike