Jesus was not a christian and other news


I know you know all this and more, but I thought you might need to know that we don’t know whether the Jesus of the bible walked this earth.

So for your Monday reading, why not this

About makagutu

As Onyango Makagutu I am Kenyan, as far as I am a man, I am a citizen of the world

35 thoughts on “Jesus was not a christian and other news

  1. john zande says:

    I want them to now do Batman.

    Like

  2. ladysighs says:

    I remember singing “I Love to Tell the Story” over and over again.
    You must admit the Bible thumpers are great song writers. The tunes are easy to remember and not hard to play on the piano.

    Like

  3. Barry says:

    I thought maybe I’d learn something new, but it’s more or less a simplified version of what what’s been known by biblical scholars and theologians for quite some time – a radical religious (mostly) nonviolent peace activist who may or may not have lived in the 1st century C.E.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Nan says:

    Too much reading (and boring at that) so I’ll take your word for it … 😛

    Liked by 1 person

  5. kiabooks says:

    No. The Jesus of the NT never walked the actual physical earth. There was prob a “Joshua” rabbi who rabble roused trying to get the Jews to take their country/regional homeland back from Roman control. But he was executed for his sedition… and there is no evidence that he actually rose from the dead. Stories for disappointed and disillusioned Messianic Jews at the time to “explain” why their Hopes and his promises never came to fruition.

    Liked by 1 person

    • makagutu says:

      Given that Joshua/ Jeshua was a common name, there must definitely have been one among them so confused to think himself god like we have seen many others after.

      Like

      • kiabooks says:

        A good jewish/Israelite Joshua would never have confused himself with the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. If there was a joshua/Jesus rabbi/rabble rouser who was the base for the “story built up by accretion”, he himself would have been the first to pick up stones to execute anyone who claimed such nonsensical blasphemy.

        Liked by 1 person

    • RaPaR says:

      I think there’s enough evidence that a person named Yeshua (of which “Jesus” would have been the Greek translation) actually lived & died in the early first century.

      Like

      • Nan says:

        Further, Yeshua was one of the most common male names in that period. (Actually, the Greek translation is “Iēsous”).

        I wrote a post in 2016 (What’s in a Name, Part 1) and outlined the changes in his name.

        Liked by 1 person

      • makagutu says:

        There is ample evidence that guy named James died 100 years ago. As James is a common name, how do we come from James to the specific James?

        Liked by 1 person

        • Judy Thompson says:

          It’s like a game of Telephone, and the further one gets away from the original whisperer the more interesting the story gets. Whoever wrote the story down was probably borrowing from oral tradition, and who ever copied the story each time would be making tiny corrections until by now Jesus could very well have been a traveling salesman named Isaac who sold shoes and fell in a well.
          The sad thing is, people still literally go to war over this. “My god is bigger than your god”…

          Liked by 1 person

          • RaPaR says:

            Yes, exactly like a “telephone game” without question. The oral tradition must have been the first source. However scholars are now sure they’re are others based on how the stories are placed in each of the first four gospels. There’s the “Q source” which Matthew & Luke must have copied from, and the other sources, “M” and “L” which scholars have hypothesized were used individually by ‘M’atthew & ‘L’uke separately. It makes sense that there must have been a number of sources since we know that none of the gospel writers were actually eyewitnesses or even knew any eyewitnesses. It’s a great detective story!

            Liked by 1 person

          • makagutu says:

            The sad thing is, people still literally go to war over this. “My god is bigger than your god”…

            This is the saddest part.

            Liked by 1 person

  6. RaPaR says:

    This is a well-honed and succinct version of the “real” Jesus story. He was a Jew; born a Jew, lived his whole life as a Jew, and was even buried as a Jew (if you believe he was actually buried. Personally, I do not. Even a superficial understanding of the nature of Pilate would convince one that he was left on the cross until his bones literally fell off. Also, who’s this “Joseph of Arimathea” that shows up and Pilate allows him to take the body for burial. No way that happened.) There are comments by him as to how important “scripture” is (it could only have been Hebrew scripture since “Christian” scripture didn’t exist yet) although he referred to it as The Law, which Jews would have characterized it. I don’t believe he thought he was “god” (he makes reference to god as a separate entity e.g., No one will know the day or hour of the coming of the new kingdom, not even the son but only the father”.) He MAY have thought he was the messiah since the messiah is supposed to be a human, not a super-human or god.) Besides, the title “Son of God” had nothing to do with being a deity. It was from 2nd Samuel 7 where god makes a covenent with David saying “I will be your father and you will be as my son.” It was a title for the messiah.

    Good stuff here though. I have some family members I’m going to have read it. (They’re tired of hearing it from me!) Thanks!

    Liked by 2 people

  7. Ron says:

    Mon Dieu! Are you suggesting that Jesus wasn’t the man he’s been made out to be?

    This is shocking news.

    Like

  8. Judy Thompson says:

    The part of this entire thing that fascinates me, is that people who revere Jesus forget that he wasn’t a ‘white man”, and the god we worship was a Jewish god. Even as a kid, immersed in Catholicism, I puzzled over that. Jesus was born and raised as a Jew, his mom was a Jewish lady.
    following the bible as if it were real has become the equivalent of regarding “Lotd of the Rings’ as our go-to bible. And maybe in a few hundred years Frodo and Sam will be our new Messiahs…

    Liked by 1 person

    • makagutu says:

      Jesus will make everyone white as snow and as such he must have been white. The rest about his being Jewish and most likely brown are details only the godless are concerned with

      Like

    • RaPaR says:

      It’s not that they had forgotten that he was a Jew, it’s that they were taught that Jesus changed everything; abrogated the “Old Testament” (i.e., the Hebre Bible) by dying on the cross for the salvation of others. This was one of the ways they “de-Judaized” (if you will) scripture. This is a ridiculous notion since, according to the Hebrew Bible (which Jesus would have been fluent in, the “New Testament” hadn’t yet existed) the Messiah was not a supernatural being, he was a man, which Jesus would have known. If fact, he realized that he was not the Messiah the moment he was arrested in Gethsemane since god was supposed to begin the wars of retribution against the Romans where no weapons were necessary since god would have wiped out the enemies of Israel himself. This is where the Catholic Church relies on the teachings of Paul whom never met Jesus, doesn’t seem to know almost anything about him, and “Hellenized” his teachings into the nonsense we call “Christianity” today.

      Liked by 1 person

      • makagutu says:

        Now tell a Christian Jesus even if he lived wouldn’t have been a Christian by any stretch of imagination.

        Like

        • RaPaR says:

          I do it all the time. Very simply, if you want to be a follower of Jesus, you have to be Jewish, period. Not only was he born, raised, and died as a Jew, he specifically told people they needed to adhere to the Law themselves. He’s quite adamant and clear on this issue.

          Like

          • Nan says:

            Thing is … Christians are essentially following PAUL. They THINK they’re following Jesus, but are totally misinformed.

            Liked by 1 person

            • RaPaR says:

              Yes, and they don’t even know that, as you point out. How then, is it possible to invest so much faith into something you know so little about? I’ve asked that question also, many times, never got even a decent answer.

              Liked by 1 person

We sure would love to hear your comments, compliments and thoughts.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s